Ads audit · 18 Nov 2025 – 17 Nov 2026 · checked against Shopify

Twelve Board Store: Google & Meta

What's working, what isn't, what it means and what to do next. Google and Meta are kept separate, and Shopify is the source of truth: both platforms claim credit for many of the same orders.

HeadlineThe platforms over-claim. In 2026 they claim 126% of every sale Shopify recorded. On Shopify, Google returns 3.85x and Meta 0.77x; overall, ads return 7.3x.
Biggest gapMeta reports 10.9x but Shopify credits it with 281 orders all year. Some of Meta's effect shows up later as Google or direct sales, so test before cutting deep.
Next month (December)Shift to Google 65% / Meta 35% at the same ~A$28k. Keep Meta's retargeting and sale ads; pause what isn't selling on Shopify.
A$248.7k
Spend, 12 months
4,924
Purchases (Shopify pixel)
A$2.51M
Purchase value
10.1x
Return on ad spend
A$50.51
Cost per purchase
14.1x
Last 4 weeks (A$38 a sale)
3.85x
Real return on Shopify, 2026

What's working

  • Confirmed by Shopify: Google brings 32% of store revenue (2,463 orders, A$846k net in 2026) at a real 3.85x and A$89 per order.
  • Brand Search is the best campaign: 18.6x at A$31 a sale, Quality Score 10/10.
  • The two big Performance Max campaigns carry the account: Performing Brands 11.9x on A$45k, All Remaining 11.1x on A$52k.
  • 146 best-selling products made 29% of product sales at 12.4x.
  • Pricier products pay back more: 8.0x under A$150, rising to 15.3x above A$1,500.
  • Getting better: cost per sale fell from A$57 to A$23 over the last 4 weeks.
  • Mobile works as well as desktop (A$50 vs A$53 a sale), and WA, SA and Tasmania return 11–15x.

What's not working

  • Google claims about 2.2x what Shopify records: A$2.10M of value in 2026 against A$938k of Shopify sales from Google ads. Divide Google's ROAS by about 2.2 for the real figure.
  • "Conversions" overstate sales: 31% (2,232) are store visits, directions and calls counted at A$1 each.
  • Budgets were cut in October: about A$22k a month down to a ~A$12.7k pace, while return rose. Brand Search lost 27% of its searches to budget over the year.
  • Paying Performance Max for brand searches: A$4,747 (45% of brand-search spend) ran there instead of the cheaper brand campaign.
  • Low ad rank: Performance Max loses 63% of eligible searches on rank; the store shows in under 10% of searches and rivals rank above it 59–73% of the time.
  • Wrong bidding on high-ticket items: Jones and Fatboy bid on number of sales, not value (Fatboy averages A$1,566 an order).
  • Waste in the long tail: 3,291 rarely-selling products took A$34.9k at 3.5x; 45 products took A$8.4k with almost no sales.

Insights

  • Two different ceilings: budget limits Brand Search; ad rank limits Performance Max. Extra money helps the first, better feeds and bidding fix the second.
  • Value grows with ticket size, so e-bikes, e-boards and premium snowboards should bid on order value with their own budget.
  • Searches for product brands and models (Fatboy, Jones, Onewheel, Burton) are 68% of search-term spend at 9.5x; generic searches like "snowboard" return 6.4x; brand searches 25x.
  • Melbourne Snowboard is the main rival: it competes in 27.6% of the same searches and ranks above Twelve Board Store in 72.7% of them.
  • 35 campaigns ran this year and 26 are paused. Constant relaunches reset learning; six steady campaigns would learn faster.
  • Shopify sales from Google held up after the October cut: A$22.8k spend brought A$68.7k in September, A$16.3k brought A$68.8k in October, and A$8.1k brought A$85.4k in 1–20 November (Black Friday early access). Add budget back gradually and watch Shopify, not Google's ROAS.
  • 108 products are blocked in Merchant Center for a price mismatch between feed and website. They sold little, but Black Friday price changes make this spread.

Action plan

Search – BrandExact + phrase, store sitelinks
A$40/day
PMax – Best Sellers146 hero products, target ROAS 900%
A$180/day
PMax – SnowBoards, boots, bags, outerwear
A$150/day
PMax – E-mobilityFatboy, FlightRisk, Onewheel, value bidding
A$120/day
PMax – Skate & lifestyleLower-ticket lines, target ROAS 600%
A$50/day
Local PMaxStore visits, reported separately
A$20/day
WhenAction
This weekRaise budgets before Black Friday: Brand Search A$20→A$40, Performing Brands and All Snowboard A$90→A$130, Fatboy A$10→A$40.
This weekAdd a brand exclusion to every Performance Max campaign except Local.
This weekReport purchases only; set store visits, directions and calls to secondary outside Local PMax.
This weekFix feed prices for the 108 disapproved products and turn on automatic item updates in Merchant Center.
Week 1Switch Jones and Fatboy to bid on conversion value. Add rival-store names as negative keywords.
Week 1Change the tracking template to utm_campaign={campaignid} so Shopify shows which Google campaign made each sale.
Week 2Label products in Merchant Center (hero / line / exclude) and launch Best Sellers and E-mobility.
Week 3–4Merge the snow and skate campaigns into the six-campaign structure; archive 7 unused purchase actions.
Week 6+Exclude the 45 no-sale products for 60 days; move new 5+ sale products into Best Sellers monthly; change budgets 20% at a time.