What's working, what isn't, what it means and what to do next. Google and Meta are kept separate, and Shopify is the source of truth: both platforms claim credit for many of the same orders.
| When | Action |
|---|---|
| This week | Raise budgets before Black Friday: Brand Search A$20→A$40, Performing Brands and All Snowboard A$90→A$130, Fatboy A$10→A$40. |
| This week | Add a brand exclusion to every Performance Max campaign except Local. |
| This week | Report purchases only; set store visits, directions and calls to secondary outside Local PMax. |
| This week | Fix feed prices for the 108 disapproved products and turn on automatic item updates in Merchant Center. |
| Week 1 | Switch Jones and Fatboy to bid on conversion value. Add rival-store names as negative keywords. |
| Week 1 | Change the tracking template to utm_campaign={campaignid} so Shopify shows which Google campaign made each sale. |
| Week 2 | Label products in Merchant Center (hero / line / exclude) and launch Best Sellers and E-mobility. |
| Week 3–4 | Merge the snow and skate campaigns into the six-campaign structure; archive 7 unused purchase actions. |
| Week 6+ | Exclude the 45 no-sale products for 60 days; move new 5+ sale products into Best Sellers monthly; change budgets 20% at a time. |
| When | Action |
|---|---|
| This week | Exclude past buyers from every prospecting ad set before Black Friday. |
| This week | Turn off Audience Network and judge Meta on the 7-day-click column. |
| This week | Pause the two live campaigns weakest on Shopify: Electrics catalogue and "Yes, K2 and Jones" (A$34k, 4 Shopify orders). Total Meta budget to about A$320/day (35%). |
| Week 1 | Merge the ~11 live sales campaigns into the 5-campaign structure, keeping the best ads. |
| Week 1 | Point catalogue ads at in-stock products only; build a "Google best sellers" product set. |
| Week 1 | Cap retargeting at under 4 views a week and widen it to 30-day viewers and engagers. |
| Week 2–3 | Shoot 6–8 vertical videos: e-bike test rides at Richmond, snowboard unboxings, staff picks. |
| Week 3–4 | A/B test bidding on number of sales vs sale value. |
| January | Run a 4-week Meta conversion-lift (holdout) test and read it against Shopify before any deeper cut. |
| Month 2+ | Judge Google and Meta together against Shopify total sales each month. |
Shopify credits each order once, to the last ad click with a UTM tag. "Real return" = Shopify net sales (after discounts and refunds, before tax and shipping) ÷ spend.
| Google Ads | Meta Ads | |
|---|---|---|
| Spend | A$219,984 | A$143,565 |
| Purchases the platform claims | 3,944 | 2,537 (1,271 clicked) |
| Value the platform claims | A$2.10M | A$1.57M (A$839k clicked) |
| Shopify orders | 2,463 | 281 |
| Shopify net sales | A$845,868 | A$109,969 |
| Over-claim on value (claimed ÷ Shopify total sales) | 2.2x | 12.9x |
| Return as the platform claims it | 9.5x | 10.9x (5.8x clicked) |
| Real return (Shopify) | 3.85x | 0.77x |
| Cost per order, platform's figure | A$56 | A$57 |
| Cost per Shopify order | A$89 | A$511 |
| 2026 | Google spend | Google claims | Google real | Meta spend | Meta claims | Meta clicked | Meta real | Claims ÷ all sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan | A$21.5k | 11.1x | 3.7x | A$14.8k | 12.0x | 7.1x | 0.8x | 133% |
| Feb | A$20.4k | 7.4x | 3.2x | A$14.2k | 8.7x | 4.3x | 0.8x | 130% |
| Mar | A$22.0k | 11.3x | 2.8x | A$11.6k | 13.2x | 7.0x | 0.9x | 138% |
| Apr | A$21.3k | 9.2x | 2.4x | A$14.4k | 9.7x | 6.1x | 0.5x | 138% |
| May | A$19.7k | 7.8x | 3.5x | A$12.8k | 9.8x | 5.6x | 0.6x | 114% |
| Jun | A$22.9k | 9.7x | 4.6x | A$12.4k | 11.4x | 5.4x | 0.4x | 115% |
| Jul | A$22.8k | 9.0x | 3.9x | A$16.2k | 10.5x | 5.6x | 0.8x | 127% |
| Aug | A$22.1k | 10.8x | 4.5x | A$13.3k | 10.0x | 5.3x | 0.9x | 133% |
| Sep | A$22.8k | 7.3x | 3.0x | A$10.0k | 12.9x | 6.9x | 1.1x | 123% |
| Oct | A$16.3k | 8.9x | 4.2x | A$15.3k | 9.6x | 4.1x | 0.3x | 128% |
| Nov 1–20 | A$8.1k | 16.0x | 10.6x | A$8.5k | 15.0x | 8.3x | 1.6x | 100% |
| Source | Sales | Share | Orders | Avg order |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No UTM (direct, organic, untagged email, returning) | A$1.31M | 45% | 2,365 | A$554 |
| Google Ads | A$938k | 32% | 2,463 | A$381 |
| Draft Orders (phone / in-store quotes) | A$468k | 16% | 474 | A$987 |
| Meta Ads | A$122k | 4% | 281 | A$433 |
| ChatGPT and Perplexity | A$24k | 0.8% | 46 | A$521 |
| Marketplace, Shop app, referrals, other | A$56k | 2% | 217 | |
| Total | A$2.92M | 100% | 5,846 | A$499 |
| When | Action |
|---|---|
| December | Move to Google 65% / Meta 35% at the same ~A$28k (budget memo). Judge both on Shopify each month. |
| This week | Pause Meta's Electrics catalogue and "Yes, K2 and Jones" campaigns; keep retargeting and the sale catalogue. |
| This week | Fix feed prices for the 108 disapproved Merchant Center products before Black Friday prices change again. |
| Week 1 | Tracking: Google template to utm_campaign={campaignid}; UTMs on for every Klaviyo email and flow; a source note on every Draft Order. |
| Week 2 | Find out why Meta e-bike orders get refunded (finance declines, delivery area, sizing) before spending more on e-mobility. |
| January | 4-week Meta conversion-lift (holdout) test, read against Shopify, to settle Meta's real value. |
| Shopify | Google / Meta |
|---|---|
| UTM source + medium | google / cpc = Google Ads; facebook / paid (fb, ig) = Meta |
| UTM campaign name | Meta campaign name; Google only "Google Shopping" / "pmaxmanual" |
| Orders | Google Conversions (Shopify-pixel purchase) / Meta Purchases |
| Total sales | Conversion value / purchase value (closest match) |
| Net sales | No equivalent: real revenue after discounts and refunds |
| Sales reversals | No equivalent: platforms never take refunds back |
| Sales channel | Only Online Store is visible to the pixels |